Free to compare · No sign-up
How it worksAd disclosure
Article

Missouri Is Rewriting Its Not-at-Fault Rule. The Draft Takes the Dollar Figure Off Your Rate-Hike Notice.

Missouri has barred rate increases for crashes you didn't cause since 1978. Its proposed rewrite, effective for policies from January 1, 2028, adds weather damage, the under-50% fault line and a ban on quiet tier moves. It also drops the rule that your notice says how much of the increase came from a claim. Comments close about December 16.

Melting hailstones on green grass in morning sun after a storm

If you drive in Missouri, your insurer already can’t raise your rate over a crash you didn’t cause. That’s been the rule since 1978. The state is now rewriting it, and the draft is better for you in almost every way but one.

The one is the line on your renewal that says how much of the increase came from a claim. The draft drops it.

What Missouri is changing

The current rule, 20 CSR 500-2.600, is blunt: “In no event shall an insurer request an increase in premium from any insured in connection with any claim arising out of any accident for which the insured was not at fault.” It lists the classic cases. You were lawfully parked. You got rear-ended and weren’t ticketed. You hit a deer. Gravel cracked the windshield.

On November 16, the Department of Commerce and Insurance published its replacement, 20 CSR 500-2.650, for policies issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2028. It closes real gaps.

Weather damage joins the not-at-fault list. Hail claims count. So does any accident where you were found “less than fifty percent (50%) at fault.” The hit-and-run protection no longer depends on reporting the crash within 24 hours, a condition the old rule carried.

The best line goes after the back door. An insurer can’t use a not-at-fault accident to charge you more “through classification, reclassification, tiering, or any other manner.” Translation: no quietly bumping you into a pricier tier and calling it something other than a surcharge. And when the file is thin, an insurer “may not assume that an accident is at fault.”

The department pegs the industry’s total cost at $350,000. For a statewide rewrite of auto rating, that’s a rounding error.

Here’s the catch

Today, any notice that raises your premium because of claims must “specifically state the reasons for the increase in premiums and the percentage or dollar amount of this increase which is applicable to accident claims.” Insurers also have to submit those notices to the department before they use them.

The draft keeps a notice, but it only has to identify “the motor vehicle incident or other loss event that resulted in the higher premium.” No percentage. No dollar amount. The old rule, amended to cover only policies issued or renewed before 2028, takes its disclosure line with it.

That number is what tells you whether to fight or shop. Say your renewal jumps $300 and the notice names an at-fault fender bender. Was $40 of that the claim and $260 a base rate increase? Or all $300? Without the split, you can’t tell whether a dispute is worth your time or whether your carrier just got expensive.

Verdict: a good rule with one bad edit. Fix the edit.

Do this

Send a comment by about December 16, 30 days after Register publication. Email [email protected] and ask the department to keep the percentage or dollar amount requirement in the new notice. Two sentences is enough.

Pull your CLUE report this week. The draft lets insurers rely on claims-history databases “unless proof to the contrary is received” from you, so a wrong fault flag stays wrong until you send the proof. Our CLUE report guide walks through the free copy and the dispute.

If you got a surcharge for a not-at-fault claim this year, you don’t need to wait for 2028. Ask your insurer in writing which claim caused it, then file a complaint with the department if the answer is a parked car or a deer. To check whether your quote is out of line, run it through our insurance estimator.

The detail

The authority is section 379.470, RSMo, which bars unfairly discriminatory rates. The public hearing is at 10:00 a.m. on December 22, 2026, in Room 530 at 301 West High Street, Jefferson City. The department notes that the official text is the version in the Missouri Register, not the copy on its website.

How Candid Yak makes money. Some of the products we write about pay us if you apply or sign up through our links. That never changes our verdict, our rankings, or the numbers in this article. We call a bad deal a bad deal whether it pays us or not. Some brands shown in our comparison tools are placeholder examples while we finalize partner agreements, and we label them as such.

Frequently asked questions

Can a Missouri insurer raise my rate for an accident that wasn't my fault?

No, and that's true today, not just under the proposal. Missouri's rule 20 CSR 500-2.600, in force since 1978, says an insurer can't request a premium increase over any claim from an accident where you weren't at fault. It lists cases such as being lawfully parked, being rear-ended when you weren't convicted of a moving violation, hitting an animal, and flying gravel or falling objects. The proposed replacement, 20 CSR 500-2.650, keeps the ban and widens it for policies issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2028.

What changes under the proposed Missouri rule?

The draft defines a not-at-fault accident to include being found less than 50% at fault, being reimbursed by the other party, and damage from weather events, animals, flying gravel or falling objects. It bars insurers from using a not-at-fault accident to charge you more 'through classification, reclassification, tiering, or any other manner,' and says an insurer 'may not assume that an accident is at fault' when it lacks information. The current rule's requirement that a rate-hike notice state the percentage or dollar amount of the increase tied to claims does not carry over. The new notice only has to identify the incident.

How do I comment on the Missouri not-at-fault rule?

Email [email protected] or mail the Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance, PO Box 690, Jefferson City, Missouri 65102. Comments must be received within 30 days of the rule's publication in the November 16, 2026 Missouri Register, which works out to about December 16. A public hearing is set for 10:00 a.m. on December 22, 2026, in Room 530 at 301 West High Street in Jefferson City.

Ready to compare?

Find your best Auto Insurance match in 2 minutes.

Free to compare. No spam, no commitment.