If a life insurer ever turned you down or quoted you a rate that made no sense, the reason may have come from a report you’ve never seen. And it may not even have been about you.
Milliman, a Seattle firm, has agreed to pay $15.5 million to settle a class action over its IntelliScript reports. That’s the prescription and medical history file life insurers pull when you apply. The proposed deal covers about 780,965 people, according to a settlement summary Top Class Actions published November 3.
How a stranger’s prescriptions land in your file
Here’s how the Ninth Circuit described the system in a January 9 ruling that revived the case. When you apply, the insurer sends Milliman your name, birth date, gender, Social Security number and ZIP code. Milliman pulls records from pharmacies, pharmacy benefit managers and health insurers.
About 87% of what it matches is tied to your Social Security number. The rest gets matched on name, birth date, ZIP and gender, sometimes through what the court called “fuzzy matching”: nicknames, reversed first and last names, names with “the same consonants.” Those records can land in your report even when they carry a different Social Security number.
Then Milliman flags the file. Green is low risk. Red, in Milliman’s own words quoted by the court, means the insurer has “[n]o need [to] review” the application and should decline it.
The named plaintiff, James Healy, applied for life insurance in April 2020. His report carried another person’s records and Social Security number, plus red flags for liver disease, diabetes, sleep apnea and more. The court says he “had a clean bill of health.” He was denied anyway, and Milliman “failed to timely investigate or correct the errors” when he complained.
“Fuzzy” is a strange word to hear about your medical history.
What the settlement pays, and when
Not yet. The deal was filed for preliminary approval and has no claim form or deadline. Class members will get an email or postcard and at least 60 days to file.
About $9 million goes to people who file valid claims, paid by points. Disputed reports and incomplete file disclosures earn fewer points than a mismatched record. The summary estimates payouts of $30 to $1,000. Spread $9 million across all 780,965 people and it’s $11.52 each, so the real check depends on how many people bother.
The check is the small prize. A clean report is the big one, because a red flag can cost you the policy itself.
Verdict: a five-minute request is worth making, especially before you shop for term life.
Do this before your next life insurance application
Get your free report. The CFPB lists the routes: rxhistories.com/for-consumers/, (877) 211-4816, or mail to Milliman IntelliScript, P.O. Box 2223, Brookfield, WI 53008. If Milliman has a file on you, the copy is free.
Read every prescription. Anything you never filled, dispute it. The company has to investigate for free.
Got denied or rated up recently? Find the notice. Federal law requires an insurer that turns you down or charges you more based on a consumer report to tell you which reporting company supplied it and that you can get a free copy. If it names Milliman, you may fall into one of the settlement’s classes. Keep that letter for when the claim form shows up.
Then compare coverage on our life insurance hub with a clean file in hand.
How Candid Yak makes money. Some of the products we write about pay us if you apply or sign up through our links. That never changes our verdict, our rankings, or the numbers in this article. We call a bad deal a bad deal whether it pays us or not. Some brands shown in our comparison tools are placeholder examples while we finalize partner agreements, and we label them as such.
Sources
- $15.5M class action settlement proposed over inaccurate life insurance reports (Top Class Actions, November 3, 2026)
- Healy v. Milliman, Inc., No. 24-3327, opinion (U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, January 9, 2026)
- Milliman IntelliScript, consumer reporting companies list (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau)
- 15 U.S. Code 1681m: Requirements on users of consumer reports (Fair Credit Reporting Act, Legal Information Institute)